Free Audit

Simple Trust Badge Test Delivers 12.2% Conversion Rate Boost

Trust badge A/B test results showing conversion and revenue improvements
The Client

Home Plans Marketplace

Executive Summary
A residential architecture plan retailer needed to build trust for high-value digital purchases. Our strategic placement of Norton trust badges alongside existing security indicators delivered a 12.2% conversion rate lift and 16.6% revenue increase.

Highlights

Our A/B test identified the optimal trust badge combination for digital purchases. Adding Norton badges alongside existing security indicators increased conversion rate by 12.2%, grew transactions by 14.3%, and improved total revenue by 16.6% during the test period.

The Challenge

Our client faced a common e-commerce challenge: convincing users to make high-value purchases of digital products. Despite having McAfee trust badges in place, analytics showed potential for strengthening security signals throughout the purchase journey.

Our Solution 💡

After analyzing user behavior patterns, we identified two strategic variations for testing:

  • Variation 1: Norton badge strategically positioned to the left of the existing 100% secure badge
  • Variation 2: Norton badge completely replacing the current 100% secure badge

Our hypothesis was simple: by adjusting the placement and combination of trust signals, we could enhance user confidence without disrupting the purchase flow.

Technical Implementation ⚡

We launched a AB test across the entire site with equal traffic distribution between variations.

Control: Original desktop layout displays a single McAfee trust indicator without additional security badges.
Winning Variation: Optimized layout featuring the Norton trust badge placed next to the existing security indicator. This winning variation demonstrates the enhanced trust signaling that led to a 12.2% conversion rate improvement.

The Results

Let's break down the numbers:

Metric Control Variation 2 Lift
Users 1,724 1,756 -
Transactions 84 96 14.3%
Conversion Rate 4.87% 5.47% 12.2%
Revenue Lift - - 16.6%

Why It Worked 🎯

The winning variation proved that strategic placement of multiple trust badges directly impacts purchase confidence. Our results confirmed that reducing purchase anxiety through recognized security signals is particularly effective for high-value digital products, where customer trust is essential to completing transactions.

💬 Let's Talk

Ready to optimize your trust signals? Let's discuss how we can apply these insights to your business.

Appendix: Detailed Test Parameters and Statistical Analysis

Test Parameters

Parameter Detail
Device targeting Desktop and mobile devices
Browser targeting All modern browsers (IE 11+)
User segments All visitors
Page scope Global site implementation

Statistical Analysis

Metric Value
Confidence level 95%
Sample size 3,480 users
Z-score 1.97
P-value 0.049
Conservative lift estimate 12.2%
Field Notes
"We used to do quite a bit of trust badge testing, and while it's still somewhat effective, it's not nearly as impactful as it once was.  That said, careful placement of trust elements and imagery can still move the needle in 2025, but don't rely on 5 year old 'best practices' to guide you."
Devon Cox President, ConversionTeam
NEXT STEPS

Let’s Talk Conversion

Ready to see if our companies are a good fit? Get a free Quick Wins CRO Audit or reach out to start a conversation
cross menu linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram